ClinGen - Dosage, little evidence for haploinsufficiency (2013). GenCC - Strong for AD visceral heterotaxy (INVITAE). BabySeq - none. HGMD curated LOF variants below
Clinical Validity Scoring Notes and points
NODAL IS LOF CONSTRAINED, LOEUF 0.31. Note there is an alternate start codon in exon 2 that is used by transcripts NM_001329906
EXON 1
c.123_142dup20 p.(Tyr48Trpfs*5) - NMD+, located in exon 1, absent gnomAD.
PMID: 30293987 - Identified in family 195 and 835.
Per supplement, in family 195, the variant was found in proband with functional single ventricle, segregated in affected sib with a VSD, but was inherited from the unaffected father. 1 POINT (downgrading due to reduced penetrance)
In family 835, the variant was found in proband with dextrocardia, DORV, AVSD, PS, RAA, PDA, left SVC persisting to coronary sinus, asplenia and was inherited from father with “hole in heart”. 2 POINTS
Being generous, counting 2 affected segregations across both families. REDUCED PENETRANCE
c.182T>A p.L61Q - absent gnomad REVEL Score: 0.690. PMID: 22352765 - requested article, per HGMD found in patient with Congenital heart disease
Quickly reviewed the other exon 1 missense variants in this gene from HGMD, reported in PMID: 19553149, 34666056. No segregations reported, no de novo variants. All would be VUS at maximum.
EXON 2
c.194-1G>T - absent gnomad v2, NMD+ variant, located in intron 1.
PMID: 19064609 (2009) - found in one individual per table 1. Table 2, reported in a patient with dextrocardia, single ventricle, DILV, PA, hypoplastic tricuspid valve annulus.
PMID: 30622330 - overlaping authors with PMID: 19064609, same proband reported LAT0022. Variant inherited from unaffected father, and shared by an affected paternal aunt. 1 POINT (DOWNGRADE FOR REDUCED PENETRANCE)
PMID: 29368431 reported in patient 9 with double outlet right ventricle and transposition of the great arteries. Also had a variant in CITED2 which is also associated with congenital heart disease (moderate curations by LMM and Ambry), but this variant is present in 54/58840 admixed american alleles in gnomAD. 2 POINT
c.692G>A p.W231* - EXON 2. 3 alleles gnomAD v4, NMD+. PMID: 34328347 Found in a cohort of patients with tetralogy of Fallot. 2 POINTS
c.700_707delAGGCACCG p.(Arg234Serfs*41) - absent gnomAD NMD +. PMID: 30622330 - Found in patient LAT1763M with conotruncal heart defect. PER TEXT INHERITED FROM UNAFFECTED PARENT REDUCED PENETRANCE, DOWNGRADE 1 POINTS
Also found in LAT0191 with a complex defect. See table 2; but this individual is also reported in PMID: 19064609 WITH A different in frame variant, so I am going to score conservatively under taht variant below (see c.700_723delinsTTGACTTCC)
c.891+1 G>A - located in last intron at splice donor site, unclear if NMD will occur. Absent gnomAD. P/LP by Invitae. PMID: 19064609 (2009) - reported in patient LAT0457 with dextrocardia, hypoplastic subpulmonary conus with PS, l-TGA, DORV with posterior main PA, VSD. 1 POINT
PMID: 19064609 in patient LAT0191 d-TGA, single ventricle, DILV, PA, ASD, intra-atrial re-entrant tachycardia However, this is the same patient ID reported in PMID: 30622330 and variant is descibed as a FS there. In PMID: 19553149, - per HGMD confirmed by personal communication, variant is called delSJ. Variant has 15% activity of WT based on luciferase assay. Scoring 0.5 point for non-NMD variant, but in herited from unaffected parent per text, -0.5 point, scoring just the 0.5 point for functional.
EXON 3
c.892-1G>C - last intron acceptor site, absent gnomAD, unclear if NMD will occur.
PMID: 19933292 - reported in proband of family 6 with transposition of the great arteries. Also had a variant in CFC1, which also is scored as strong for heterotaxy in GenCC by Invitae. No points due to potential alternate cause.
c.919C>T p.R307* - NMD-, absent gnomAD.
PMID: 30293987 per supplement, in family 3766, found in proband with TGA, VSD, PDA, but inherited from mother who only had a heart murmur. 1 POINTREDUCED PENETRANCE
LOF citations from Invitae PMID: 19064609, 19933292
EXPERIMENTAL PMID: 12730124 - In mice “ It is well established that Nodal heterozy-gotes are normal and are born in expected Mendelian ratios” . However double het mice with Zic3 / NODAL haploinsufficient are born in reduced numbers.
PMID: 19064609 - the missense variants identified in patients with were tested using a luciferase reporter assay and found decrease signaling. However, many of the probands reported had the Gly260Arg variant which has a relatively high MAF in gnomAD (0.2%, 78/35440 Admixed american gAD v4. Variants were shown to have found decreased expression on Western blot in P19 cells, mislocalization of phospho-Smad2 in cells transfected with NODAL variant constructs
Clinical ValidityPoints Total
11.5
Source:
Clinical ValidityClassification
Definitive (12pts)
Strong (12pts)
Moderate (7-11pts)
Limited (0.1-6pts)
No genetic evidence
Refuted
Disputed
Moderate
Source:
MolecularMechanism
Loss of function
Gain of function
Dominant negative
Unknown
Other
Loss of function
See variants scored under clinical validity.
Note, there is an alternate start site in exon 2 (codon 134 in MANE select NM_018055.2). However, several truncations upstream of this have been reported:
Exon 1 - c.123_142dup20 p.(Tyr48Trpfs*5) two cases in PMID: 30293987
Exon 2 -
c.194-1G>T in one case (PMID: 19064609 and PMID: 30622330 - overlaping authors with PMID: 19064609, same proband reported LAT0022)
c.397C>T p.Q133* - one case in PMID: 29368431
These variants support that the MANE transcript is important and that LOF upstream of p.134 including exon 1 are LP.
PMID: 30293987, 19064609, 34328347
Penetrance
Complete (100%)
High (≥80%)
Moderate (<80% and >20%)
Low (≤20%)
(list source/PMID)
Unknown but incomplete penetrance has been observed
The NODAL gene is associated with autosomal dominant congenital heart defects and laterality defects. Observed features include single functional ventricle, double outlet right ventricle, transposition of the great arteries, conotruncal heart defects such as tetralogy of Fallot, pulmonic stenosis, hypoplastic tricuspid valve annulus, septal defects, dextrocardia, and asplenia (PMID: 30622330, 34328347, 30293987, 19064609, 19933292). Reduced penetrance has been observed (PMID: 30622330, 19064609).